Camelbak vs. Yeti vs. Hydro Flask Bottles

The market for water bottles, tumblers, and flasks has exploded in recent years, and the quality of products has taken a big step forward.  The days of plain, plastic water bottles are going away.  Instead, high-quality, BPA-free, insulated bottles are becoming the new norm.  These are bottles that, if cared for properly, will last you for a long, long time.

When it comes to higher-end water bottles, we wanted to compare three of the brands that seem to have great traction and lots of buzz:  Camelbak, Yeti, and Hydro Flask.  We want to give your our opinion of which bottles work best, stand up to repeated use, and provide the best insulation performance.

Camelbak Bottles

Camelback Podium Big Chill 25. Tops for cycling.

Known just as much for their hydrating backpacks as their water bottles, the Camelbak brand is one of the more popular brands on the market today.  In business since 1988, they have stood the test of time as a maker of hydration products.  Camelbak was originally borne out of the loyal cycling community (the genesis group for many new mainstream products) but today is a well-known brand carried by most major retailers.

Our favorites:

Camelbak Chute 1.5L.  A larger-volume bottle that is ideal for hiking or keeping nearby during HIIT or yoga.  A high-flow spout allows for easy pouring or drinking, and it tightens shut with just a half-turn twist. Intuitive and tough.  Find here.

Camelbak Podium Big Chill.  Designed for cycling, to fit in the water holder on most bikes.  This insulated bottle keeps things cold for a long time, and holds a generous 25 oz of fluid.  BPA-free.  Allows for a squeeze gulp, which we think is an important feature for cyclists.  Find here.

Camelbak Classic Hydration Pack.  If you want to ditch the bottle and go for the hydration backpack, this is the standard.  The Classic is an all-purpose, breathable backpack that can carry a healthy 2.5 liters of fluid.  The flow provides a good drink of water with every gulp.  Find here.

Hydro Flask Bottles

Hydro Sport w/ Sport Cap

Hydro Flask as a brand is not as old as Camelbak – they were founded in 2009 – but have been growing fast and cranking out some really good bottles ever since.  Hydro Flask’s specialty seems to be insulating bottles that can keep cold drinks cold and warm drinks warm.  Think of them as the new-age Thermos.  Being based on Bend, OR, they are in a prime testing area for any outdoor gear.

Our favorites:

Hydro Flask Standard, Sport Cap.  The Standard bottle has a hard body and incredible insulative qualities.  We like it for hiking and keeping nearby during our indoor workouts.  While we have not tested it, the company says it keeps cold fluids cold for 24 hours! Comes in a 21 ounce size.  As the name suggests, this is really the all-purpose model from the hydro-flask lineup.  Just be sure you are looking for a hardbody bottle.  Find here.

Yeti Bottles

Yeti took the world by storm in 2014 when REI began carrying them, but they have been around since 2006 selling their well-known coolers.  The Austin-based company also began making fluid bottles, and they are made well.  Much of the product line is stainless, built more for outdoorsy pursuits and travel.  However, for our active audience, we think there are a few excellent options worth considering.  We love that all of these bottles are made to be dishwasher safe, something that is often overlooked but highly appreciated.

Our favorites:

Yeti Rambler 18. Great for rugged use.

Yeti Rambler 18 Oz.  An excellent, hardbody bottle, this will keep fluids hot or cold for a very long time, and is highly durable.  We like this model for activities such as hiking, kayaking, and fishing.  The double-wall vacuum insulation is some of the better engineering we have seen in these bottles.  Find here.

Yet Rambler 36 ounce.  One of Yeti’s most popular bottles. Much like the smaller version above, the 36 ounce bottle provides excellent insulation, a reliable lid, and durable construction.  It is a little larger than most cupholders and definitely too big to carry on a bike, but if you are looking to carry more fluid, this is an excellent choice.  Find here.

Our Recommendation:

So which bottle is best?  It depends on your intended use, but here is our recommendation:

Best for Cycling:  Camelbak Podium Big Chill.  Perfect size for a bike water bottle holder, and keeps your fluid cold on a hot day.

Best for HIIT, Weight, or Yoga Workouts:  Hydroflask Standard Sport Cap.  Good for a quick drink, durable.

Best for Hiking and Kayaking:   Yeti Rambler 18.  Bullet proof construction, can roll around in a canoe or fall on a rock, and will still perform.

What to Look for in High-End Bottles

There are a few things to look for in your water bottle as you are comparing.  Here are a few factors to keep in mind:

Any active person will find reasons to use one of Camelbak’s Classic Packs.

Intended Use.  Perhaps the most important factor is to match the bottle with your intended use.  Cycling, for example, requires bottles that fit in the typical bottle holder on a bike.  Running and cycling generally are most conducive to a squeezable bottle that can squirt the fluid through a nozzle.  Hiking and Kayaking are often most suited to harder-cased bottles.  If you think you will be using the bottle to keep coffee hot or water cold, be sure to go with one of the bottles with better insulating qualities.

Durability.  Making sure you have a bottle or flask that is durable is key.  Everything we recommend above has been proven to be durable – they tend to have good construction, plenty of quality control in the production, and are durable for their intended use.  But be careful when looking at cheaper models from upstart makers.  They are often simply sourcing the bottles in China and trying to sell them en masse, in many cases without even testing them first.  Pay attention not only to the bottle construction but also to the quality of the lid or nozzle.  There is nothing worse than a leaky top to your expensive bottle.

Size and Capacity.  One of the main choices you will make is on the size or fluid capacity of the bottle you buy.  This all depends on what you are using the bottle for, but just remember that a large bottle full of fluid can be quite heavy, and add lots of weight to your hike or run.  For all-purpose use, we like the 16 to 22 ounce range – that tends to be a bottle that can hydrate you for a long time, without making the vessel too heavy when full.

Price.  Price is always a factor, but the good news is that there is lots of range in the models that we recommend above.  You will find bottles that cost anywhere from $15 at the low end, to over $50 at the high end.  The Camelbak backpack runs a little more, around $60 or $70.  Just be sure to spend enough on a bottle so you don’t have to end up buying another one a month later, due to poor construction quality.  We are big proponents of buying quality upfront so you have less waste down the road.

Ease of Cleaning.  Make sure that your bottle is low maintenance.  Most bottles are dishwasher safe, and for the ones that aren’t you will just want to be sure that cleaning can be easily done.  This means not getting anything that traps liquid in small nooks that are hard to clean or rinse – and having parts that disassemble enough so you can really clean them well.

BPA Free.  BPA is a material found in many hard plastics and resins.  Studies suggest that it can leach into the food or liquid it is carrying, and then enter the human body.  Once in the body, there are a number of harmful effects that it is believed to be linked to.  This seems to be more pronounced as the bottle ages.  It is best to avoid any plastic bottles the contain BPA.

We will be happy to see your thoughts

Leave a reply

Search